The Journal of Advanced Legal Studies (JALS) is committed to maintaining honesty, fairness, transparency, confidentiality and accountability throughout manuscript submission, peer review, editorial decision-making and publication.
Authors, reviewers and editors are expected to follow responsible academic and legal research practices and to protect the accuracy, credibility and integrity of the scholarly record.
Submitted manuscripts must present original legal scholarship and acknowledge all external sources accurately.
Statutes, judgments, facts, legal principles, quotations and references must be represented honestly.
Applicable consent, confidentiality, institutional permission and participant-protection requirements must be satisfied.
Authorship, funding, conflicts of interest, methodology and relevant limitations should be disclosed clearly.
Authors must provide proper acknowledgement whenever they use another person’s words, arguments, interpretations, research findings, legal analysis, tables, figures or other intellectual material.
Direct copying, close paraphrasing, translation without attribution, inappropriate reuse of earlier work or submission of another person’s work as original may be treated as plagiarism.
Submitted manuscripts may be examined for textual similarity, duplication and improper source use during editorial processing.
| Misconduct | Description |
|---|---|
| Plagiarism | Using another person’s words, ideas, legal analysis, data or material without proper acknowledgement. |
| Data Fabrication | Inventing interviews, surveys, case records, evidence, participants or research findings. |
| Data Falsification | Changing, omitting or manipulating evidence, documents or results in a misleading manner. |
| Duplicate Publication | Publishing substantially the same manuscript more than once without transparent disclosure. |
| Simultaneous Submission | Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time. |
| Authorship Misconduct | Including non-contributors or excluding individuals who made substantial scholarly contributions. |
| Citation Manipulation | Adding irrelevant citations to influence citation counts or satisfy improper requests. |
| Peer-Review Manipulation | Providing false reviewer identities or attempting to influence independent review improperly. |
A manuscript submitted to JALS must not be under consideration by another journal at the same time.
Authors should disclose any related conference paper, thesis chapter, working paper, report, preprint or earlier publication where substantial overlap may exist.
Submitting substantially identical work to multiple publications without transparent disclosure may result in rejection or corrective action.
Authorship should be limited to individuals who made a substantial scholarly contribution.
All authors should approve the submitted manuscript and agree to the authorship order.
Academic position, reputation or institutional authority alone does not justify authorship.
Limited technical, editorial or administrative assistance may be acknowledged separately.
Legal research involving interviews, surveys, observations, personal records or identifiable individuals should respect dignity, privacy, voluntary participation and applicable ethical requirements.
Authors should not disclose confidential client communications, privileged documents, sealed court records, protected witness details, personal identifiers or commercially sensitive information without appropriate authorization.
Where confidentiality is required, names, case references, organizational details or other identifying information should be anonymized carefully.
Authors should disclose financial, institutional, professional, personal or academic interests that may influence the research, interpretation or presentation of the manuscript.
Funding sources, sponsorship and the role of any supporting organization should be identified where applicable.
Editorial decisions should be based on the manuscript’s legal relevance, academic quality, originality, ethical preparation and contribution to scholarship.
Author status, institutional influence, personal relationships, payment or commercial considerations must not guarantee acceptance or favourable treatment.
Submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports and editorial correspondence are confidential materials.
Editors and reviewers must not disclose, reproduce, distribute or use unpublished content without authorization.
Confidential manuscripts should not be uploaded to unauthorized external platforms or artificial intelligence systems.
Credible concerns may be examined confidentially, fairly and without unnecessary delay. The journal may request explanations, original data, source documents, consent records, permissions or other relevant evidence.
Authors, reviewers and editors are expected to cooperate with legitimate publication-integrity enquiries.
| Stage | General Action |
|---|---|
| Initial Assessment | The journal examines whether the allegation is specific, credible and relevant. |
| Evidence Review | Relevant manuscripts, reports, sources, records or supporting documents may be examined. |
| Author Response | The authors may be invited to provide an explanation or supporting evidence. |
| Independent Assessment | Additional editorial or specialist advice may be obtained where appropriate. |
| Decision | The journal determines whether corrective or disciplinary action is necessary. |
| Record Update | Corrections, notices or other updates may be published to protect the scholarly record. |
| Action | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Manuscript Rejection | Declines a submission affected by serious quality, originality or ethical concerns. |
| Review Suspension | Temporarily pauses editorial processing while a concern is examined. |
| Correction | Amends an error that does not invalidate the principal scholarly contribution. |
| Expression of Concern | Alerts readers to a serious unresolved matter under investigation. |
| Withdrawal | Records removal of a manuscript or publication under appropriate circumstances. |
| Retraction | Identifies an article whose findings or ethical basis are no longer reliable. |
| Institutional Communication | Refers a serious concern to the relevant institution or authority where appropriate. |
Significant errors, unreliable findings or confirmed misconduct may require a formal correction, withdrawal, expression of concern or retraction notice.
Such notices should remain connected with the affected article to preserve transparency and protect the accuracy of the legal scholarly record.
An honest error is not automatically treated as research misconduct. Authors should report significant mistakes promptly and cooperate with appropriate correction of the publication record.
The journal will consider the nature, extent and effect of the error when determining the appropriate editorial response.
Authors, reviewers and readers may submit complaints or appeals through the journal’s official communication channel.
The request should identify the relevant manuscript or article and provide specific evidence, legal reasoning or procedural grounds.
General disagreement with an editorial decision does not automatically establish malpractice or justify reversal of the decision.
| Journal Name | Journal of Advanced Legal Studies |
| Abbreviation | JALS |
| Print ISSN | 3117-6739 |
| Online ISSN | 3117-6747 |
| Primary Commitment | Originality, legal accuracy, transparency and research integrity |
| Author Duties | Responsible authorship, proper citation, ethical research and disclosure |
| Reviewer Duties | Confidential, objective and conflict-free evaluation |
| Editorial Duties | Fair decisions, confidentiality, independence and responsible handling of concerns |
| Prohibited Conduct | Plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, duplicate submission and review manipulation |
| Possible Actions | Rejection, correction, expression of concern, withdrawal or retraction |
Ethics Notice: Submission or publication does not prevent later investigation. Authors, reviewers and editors are expected to cooperate with legitimate publication-integrity enquiries and provide relevant supporting information when requested.